Evaluation

 
 
 
Rubric for both Topic and Expert Groups
 
 
 

 

Beginning

1

Developing

2

Accomplished

3

Exemplary

4

Score

Topic Group - Assistance of group members

 Group members not only rarely made sure that their own work was done, but rarely worked to help others with theirs as well.  Group members not only somewhat made sure that their own work was done, but somewhat worked to help others with theirs as well.  Group members not only usually made sure that their own work done, but also usually worked to help others with theirs as well.  Group members not only always made sure that their own work was done, but always  worked to help others with theirs as well. 

Topic Group - Information Gathered

 The information gathered by the group member was rarely accurate or useful The information gathered by the group member was somewhat accurate or useful

The information gathered by the group member was usually accurate or useful

The information gathered by the group member was always accurate or useful

Expert Group - Presentation

       A presentation was made

Expert Group - Information

 

 The information presented was not at all clear or easy to understand The information presented was somewhat clear and easy to understand The information presented was usually clear and easy to understand The information presented was always clear and easy to understand

  Expert Group - Convincing

 The argument was not at all persuasive. The argument was somewhat persuasive. The argument was very persuasive. The argument convinced me that they were right.

Topic Group - Presentation of Expert Group Material

  The information presented from the expert group was not clear or easily understood. The information presented from the expert group was somewhat clear but not really understood.  The information presented from the expert group was usually clear and generally easily understood.  The information presented from the expert group was always clear and easily understood.